Saturday, January 9, 2010
How Do You Roll The Navy Neckerchief
How much energy did the sea? A Professor of Nautical liked to test the knowledge of thermodynamics of his students with this question. The sea is enormous, and has a temperature ranging from 0 to about twenty degrees Celsius. As the temperature is a measure of particles of a substance, it is clear that millions of tons of water will always be (unless it is not at absolute zero) certain energy. Yet, no one has ever dreamed of building a power plant that would go forward with this energy. Why?
The devil is in the second law of thermodynamics, which basically says that it is impossible to completely convert heat into work *: a piece of heat will always go dispersed. And what is the maximum work that can be extracted from a given amount of heat? It depends on the temperature at which this heat is presented. If the heat source has a very high temperature, you can expect a return (ie a ratio of work produced and consumed heat) very high. If the temperature is lower, the performance declines proportionately. At the limit, when the heat is available at room temperature, the work can be obtained is practically zero.
graph of the theoretical yield of first principle. The scale of the abscissa is logarithmic. Remember that the performance of real cycle rarely exceeds half as calculated here.
The sea is the example in this initial condition: a lot of energy, but nothing usable.
It then introduces the concept of "exergy", just as the share of thermal energy that can theoretically convert into work.
And there we care? Let
bills at home. Doing a bit 'accounts, we find that a cubic meter of gas costs about 65 € c domestic, while a kWh costs 15 € c (YMMW, these figures also depend on fixed costs and the consumption brackets). Now, you have to make a comparison with homogeneous sizes, to understand something. Since "one cubic meter of electric energy" makes little sense as a concept, let's see how much energy you can get off respectively from the gas and electricity.
As regards gas, it, burning it completely and also condenses the water present in the fumes, gives us about 39 MJ (in millions of J, a unit very convenient, since the J are small children). To understand, heated from 20 ° to 100 ° five liters of water for the pasta takes about 1.67 MJ. And a kWh? The accounts are very simple: un kWh significa la potenza di un kW (1000 W) applicata per un'ora. Poiché un Watt è pari a 1 Joule al secondo, e i secondi in un'ora sono 3600, il conto è presto fatto:
1 kWh = 1000 Wh per definizione di kW
1000 Wh = 1000 W*3600 s by definition of h (hours)
1000 W * 3600 s = 3,600,000 J for math, recalling that W = J / s J = 3.6 MJ
3,600,000 by convention, M = 'a million "
So, in summary:
1 cubic meter of gas = 39MJ
1kWh = 3.6 MJ
Rapportiamoli cost:
With a cubic meter of natural gas, I pay € 65 39MJ get there: c € 65
/ 39MJ = € 1.67 c / MJ
with one kWh of electricity, I pay € 15 we get 3.6 MJ:
c € 15 / € 4.17 = 3.6 MJ c / MJ
In practice, the same amount of energy it costs us more than double if obtained with an electricity instead of gas. Why?
Simple: even the ENEL (and its competitors) use the methane to produce electricity (and if not used methane, use other systems similar cost), but, for the speeches we did before, in the conversion from heat to electricity has to throw away a piece of heat. Not surprisingly, the power plants are always made near rivers or seas, just to throw it away this excess heat, sometimes using cooling towers.
In other words, electricity is 100% exergy, can be used "as it wants," while that of gas, although abundant, has within it a lot less exergy. It can convert entirely electrical energy into heat, but not vice versa.
So, to save, use only gas and no electricity?
I wish it were that easy. The problem is that the computer, refrigerator, television, the house lights do not go to gas. The gas gives us energy to poor quality, only the "trivial" heat. Sometimes however, the energy is "fine", which can trigger a relay, to move in a diode, to activate the phosphors on a screen, just as only the electric one is able to do.
Certainly though, if one has only need to heat anything, including gas and electricity would do well to choose the gas ** in the example above of pasta, pasta gas would cost around 2.8 € c, while heated with a heating pad would cost about 7 € c.
So then heat the water with a resistance becomes extremely expensive: for each unit of energy we dissipated (converted into heat) in electrical resistance, two more are burned "empty" and released into the environment in the vicinity of power plants.
This has clearly also a flap environment, which will face in the next post.
* for the purposes of this discourse, "work" is a form of energy such as electricity, or the mechanics of an engine running.
** I'm not talking about heat pumps, which require a separate post.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 comments:
Post a Comment